Your Heeler is nipping because it was bred to take on 2,000-pound bulls. Your Husky destroyed your couch because it was bred to run 100 miles a day. Your Malinois bit someone because it's a police dog, not a pet. The dog is doing EXACTLY what centuries of selective breeding designed it to do. You're not dealing with a "behavioral problem"—you're dealing with genetics. And instead of admitting you chose looks over research, you're considering killing a perfectly healthy dog for being what it is.
Let me guess: Your dog is "aggressive." "Stubborn." "Untrainable." "Too high energy." "Obsessive." "Won't listen." And now you're considering behavioral euthanasia because you've been to three trainers who all said the same thing you refuse to hear: Your dog is doing exactly what it was bred to do, and you're the problem for choosing aesthetics over research.
I'm not here to coddle you. I'm here to tell you the truth that could save your dog's life: The dog isn't broken. Your expectations are.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Breed-Specific Behavior
Every year, thousands of dogs are euthanized not because they're dangerous, but because their owners chose a breed based on looks and are now shocked—SHOCKED—that the dog exhibits the exact traits it was selectively bred for over centuries.
You wanted a dog that looked cool. You got a dog that acts like what it was designed to be. And instead of accepting responsibility, you're blaming the dog.
Let's break down the most common cases I see—and why your "problem dog" is actually doing its job perfectly.
Case Study #1: The "Aggressive" Cattle Dog
Your complaint:
"My Heeler is constantly nipping at my kids' heels. It chases my cat relentlessly. It bit my other dog during play. It won't stop herding everything that moves. It's aggressive and I'm worried about my family's safety."
The reality:
Your dog was bred to control 2,000-pound bulls and stubborn cattle in the Australian outback. They were specifically selected for:
- • Nipping and biting heels to move livestock
- • Relentless drive that doesn't quit
- • Extreme tenacity to take on animals 20x their size
- • High pain tolerance to handle kicks from cattle
- • Suspicion of strangers (protecting the herd)
- • Dominance to control other animals
Your Heeler is doing EXACTLY what centuries of breeding designed it to do. It sees your kids running and thinks "livestock that needs to be controlled." It sees your cat and thinks "animal that needs to be herded into line."
The problem:
You saw a cute, medium-sized dog with striking coloring on Instagram and thought it would be a great family pet. You didn't research that Cattle Dogs need 3-4 hours of intense physical and mental work daily, were bred to work independently, and are not naturally social with other pets.
The Real Question: Why Are You Considering Euthanasia?
Let's be brutally honest. You're not considering behavioral euthanasia because the dog is dangerous. You're considering it because:
- 1. You refuse to admit you made a mistake choosing this breed
- 2. You don't want to put in the work these breeds require
- 3. You're too proud to rehome the dog to someone with the right lifestyle
- 4. You'd rather kill the dog than admit you were wrong
That's what this really comes down to. Ego. You wanted the aesthetic. You got the genetics. And instead of taking responsibility, you're blaming the dog.
What You Should Do Instead of Euthanasia
1. Accept Responsibility
Stop blaming the dog. Admit you chose the wrong breed for your lifestyle. This is the first step.
2. Consult a Balanced Trainer
Not a "positive-only" trainer who will tell you your Malinois just needs more treats. Find a trainer who works with working breeds and understands genetics.
3. Meet the Breed's Actual Needs
If you're keeping the dog, provide 2-3 hours of physical exercise DAILY (not walks—WORK), give the dog a job that matches its breed purpose, and implement structure and consistent training.
4. Seriously Consider Rehoming
If you can't provide what the dog needs, rehoming is not failure—it's responsible. Your ego is not worth more than your dog's life.
The Bottom Line
Your dog isn't broken. Your expectations are.
You chose a breed designed for a specific job. The dog is trying to do that job. And instead of accepting that you made an incompatible match, you're blaming the dog's genetics.
Your dog deserves better. And if you can't give it that, find someone who can.
Struggling with a Working Breed?
If you're struggling with a working breed and need help creating structure, exercise plans, and training solutions—or if you need guidance on whether rehoming is the right choice—contact Logic Unleashed. I work with "problem" dogs every day. Usually, the dog isn't the problem. The owner's expectations are.
Book Free Consultation